The battle between Apple's iPhone and Samsung's Galaxy has been
raging for years, but the latest two flagship handsets put the companies
more neck-and-neck than ever in 2014. Apple finally got the memo that
consumers like bigger, 4.7-inch form factors, while Samsung took inspiration from the iPhone 5s to create the S5's fingerprint reader.
The iPhone 6 and Galaxy S5 are the most powerful and best-looking
phones from their respective makers, but how do they stack up head to
head? We put the two popular handsets through a 10-round gauntlet to
find out.
Design
Do you like sexy or sporty? The iPhone 6 is Apple's slimmest,
sleekest smartphone yet, with curved edges that make the handset's
transition into the 4.7-inch arena a graceful one. The phone's aluminum
back panel has a smooth, premium-feeling finish, which comes in Apple's
usual trio of Silver, Space Gray and Gold color choices.
The Galaxy S5's plastic design isn't quite as seamless, but it has
some notable durability benefits. Sporting a glossy bezel and a soft,
textured back panel, the IP67-rated Galaxy S5 can endure being dunked in
1 meter of water for 30 minutes. This water resistance comes with a
caveat, though, as the flap that covers the S5's microUSB port is both
pesky and flimsy.
Both phones are comfortable to hold, though the iPhone 6's lighter
body and narrower design make it feel a bit more suited to one-handed
use. At the same time, the iPhone 6's super-smooth edges and back panel
made me feel like I could drop the phone at any moment, whereas I never
had such a worry with the S5's more-textured body.
Winner: iPhone 6. While the Galaxy S5 is water
resistant and easier to hold and grip, the iPhone 6 has one of the slimmest, most
premium-looking builds of any smartphone.
Display
The iPhone 6's 4.7-inch, 1334 x 750 display finally gives Apple fans a
comparable screen size to the 5.1-inch Galaxy S5. But the new iPhone
still lacks the full HD resolution (1920 x 1080) of Samsung's flagship.
Both smartphones proved impressively sharp when I watched an episode
of Arrow on Netflix, as I was able to see the finer details of Oliver
Queen's prickly beard and deep-green leather jacket on either device.
The Galaxy S5 proved more color-accurate in our lab tests, scoring a
Delta E rating of 0.9 (with 1 being most accurate). The iPhone 6 lagged
behind, at 3.0.
Despite this, I found skin tones and clothing colors to look a little
saturated on the Galaxy S5 and more natural on the iPhone 6 — a small
difference, but one that was immediately noticeable when watching the
episode side-by-side on both smartphones.
Winner: Galaxy S5. While the iPhone offers more-natural-looking hues, Samsung's flagship has the bigger display, and is the only one with full HD.
Audio
If you need a quick fix of music when showering or cooking dinner,
the iPhone 6 and Galaxy S5 both do apt jobs filling small rooms with
sound. The pulsing horns and sugary vocals of Taylor Swift's
"Shake It Off" sounded crisp across the board, though the iPhone 6
sounded a bit louder and clearer when I quickly alternated between the
two devices.
The iPhone 6 also proved louder in our lab tests, with an 81-decibel
output that trumps the Galaxy S5's showing of 73 decibels.
The Galaxy S5's speaker is located on the back panel, which makes the
phone less than optimal for placing on a table and playing music. The
iPhone 6's speaker rests along the bottom edge, so you won't have such a
problem when you lay that device flat.
Winner: iPhone 6. The iPhone 6 offers louder and clearer sound.
Interface
The iPhone 6 comes loaded with iOS 8, which refines the minimalist
design overhaul brought about by iOS 7. The Android-esque Control Center
makes a return, featuring quick-access buttons for functions such as
Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and Airplane Mode. And the OS' handy Spotlight search
now searches the Web instead of just your device. Plus, the multitasking
view lets you quickly dial your favorite contacts.
The Galaxy S5 runs Android 4.4.2 coated in Samsung's signature
TouchWiz skin, which makes app icons and menus look more vibrant than
stock Android (despite some clutter). Like the iPhone 6, the S5 sports a
slide-in menu for adjusting Wi-Fi and brightness, but the S5's menu has
more options (like the ability to quickly toggle location services),
and Quick Settings can be customized.
The Galaxy S5 has better widget support, allowing you to check the
weather, search Google and shop Amazon all from your home screen. The
iPhone 6 also allows for widgets, but only in the pull-down
notifications menu. The S5 additionally benefits from Multi Window mode,
which lets you split the screen between two apps.
Winner: Galaxy S5. While the iPhone 6's interface is clean and easy to navigate, the Galaxy S5's offers more functionality.
Special Features
The iPhone 6 and Galaxy S5 both gained some neat new features by
doing a fair bit of borrowing from one another; the Galaxy S5 touts a
Touch ID-esque fingerprint reader, while the iPhone 6 has adopted the
NFC tech that has graced Android phones for years.
Located on the S5's home button, the fingerprint reader on this phone
lets you register up to three digits for unlocking your phone, signing
into your Samsung account and making PayPal payments. While this added
layer of security is welcome, the S5's reader requires a vertical
finger-swipe to unlock, which sometimes takes multiple attempts.
By comparison, the iPhone 6's Touch ID sensor allowed me to unlock
the phone by simply placing my finger on the reader in any position. On
top of unlocking the iPhone, Apple's fingerprint reader also allows you
to instantly authorize iTunes purchases.
Soon, you'll be able to authorize instant mobile payments via Touch
ID. The iPhone 6's new NFC capability is designed exclusively for Apple
Pay, which will let you store payment cards to your iPhone's Passbook
and make payments at supported registers with a quick tap of your
device. Apple Pay will arrive for iPhone 6 owners by the end of October.
Meanwhile, you can already make in-store payments with the Galaxy S5 at
any location that supports the PayPal app.
The Galaxy S5's NFC capabilities go beyond mobile payments, as you
can tap another NFC-enabled Android phone to instantly share Web links
and contacts via Android Beam, or photos and documents via S Beam. You
can also use NFC on the S5 to pair it with other devices, such as select
Bluetooth speakers.
Both phones have apps built for the health conscious, but the Galaxy
S5 has one big advantage in that department: a built-in heart rate
monitor. Located under the smartphone's rear camera, the S5's sensor
usually displayed my heart rate on the S Health app just a few seconds
after I placed my pointer finger on the sensor. While the reader had
difficulty registering my finger a few times, I appreciated being able
to check my heart rate without an external accessory.
Winner: Galaxy S5. The iPhone 6 has the better fingerprint reader, but the Galaxy S5 has the more extensive feature set overall.
Camera
The Galaxy S5's 16-MP camera packs twice the pixels of the iPhone 6's 8-MP iSight sensor, but each phone's strengths and weaknesses go beyond mere megapixels.The Galaxy S5 didn't even come close on selfies, as its 2-MP front camera produced shots that were pale and grainy compared to those of the iPhone 6's FaceTime camera.
MORE: How to Take Better Photos with Your Galaxy S5
In a separate test, other editors noticed that the iPhone 6 has trouble setting white balance, but it's not an issue you'll likely notice in most of your shots.
When customizing your shots, however, the Galaxy S5 has the edge. Selective Focus lets you put the focus on either the background or foreground of a photo, while Shot and More mode lets you scrub away photobombers or create dramatic action shots.
Winner: iPhone 6. The iPhone 6's overall picture quality and zippy autofocus make it the better smartphone for shooting pictures.